US EPA seeks court sign-off on proposed June deadline for 2023 biofuel blending rule

Banner Image

The US Environmental Protection Agency would be held to a June 14, 2023, deadline to issue final biofuel blending requirements for 2023, under a proposed consent decree awaiting review by a federal district court.

The proposal submitted July 22 to the US District Court for the District of Columbia would settle litigation brought by ethanol group Growth Energy over the agency allegedly "continuing its multiyear trend of disregarding statutory deadlines" and delaying issuance of annual mandates for the Renewable Fuel Standard program.

In the settlement agreement, the EPA does not admit to any undecided issues of fact or law but agrees to sign a notice of proposed rulemaking establishing 2023 RFS requirements by Nov. 16 and to sign a final rule on the matter by June 14, 2023.

The agreement, which is expected to be approved by the court in the coming weeks, "is an important milestone in setting the pace for growth as we usher in a new era of the RFS," Growth Energy CEO Emily Skor said in a statement July 23.

The group filed a complaint with the district court in April as the Clean Air Act calls for the EPA to craft rules establishing renewable volume obligations for the 2023 and later RFS compliance years by "no later than 14 months before" the year for which the RVOs apply (Growth Energy v. Regan, et al, 1:22–cv–01191).

The complaint followed Growth Energy's previous success in getting the EPA to lockdown June 3 as the date it would issue a rule setting the amount of renewable fuel that had to be mixed with gasoline and diesel for the 2020 through 2022 compliance years.

'Irreparable' injuries

Like its prior complaint, Growth Energy argued in the April court filing that because the RVOs set by the EPA "directly dictate the level of national demand for renewable fuels," biofuel producers have and continue to suffer economic injury from EPA's delays.

Specifically, it may be too late for biofuel producers to adjust their operations to assure output meets RFS compliance requirements by the time the EPA issues the 2023 RVO, the group asserted. "This uncertainty and inability to plan future production directly affects plaintiff's members' bottom lines."

And the EPA's practice of retroactively setting RVOs to match actual renewable fuel consumption for the year causes further monetary harm as it lowers biofuel demand "in comparison to what would have been demanded" through timely RFS standards intended to spur growth in renewable fuel use, the group said.

"These injuries are irreparable," Growth Energy told the court. "Once an opportunity to plan supply or to sell renewable fuel has passed, it cannot be regained; the transportation fuel will have already been sold and used by the consumer without plaintiff's renewable fuel. And plaintiff cannot obtain compensatory damages from EPA for its unlawful actions."

Skor said the new consent decree "ensures the certainty of the 2023 RFS requirements and further underscores Growth Energy's steadfast commitment to keeping the RFS on sound footing now and into the future."

Deadline extension

The EPA posted notice of the proposed consent decree in the Federal Register May 23 and took comments through June 22 on its plan for settling charges that it had failed to perform its nondiscretionary duties.

The agency, through a court filing, said it received four comments, but it along with the Justice Department determined that none of those comments warranted withdrawing the decree or withholding their consent.

However, after the comment period, the agency and Growth Energy agreed to extend the initially proposed deadlines for EPA action. The EPA had previously agreed to having a proposed rule ready by Sept. 16 and a final rule issued by April 28, 2023.

A joint motion from the EPA and Growth Energy described the consent decree filed to the court with the later deadlines as "substantively fair and in the public interest because it establishes judicially enforceable deadlines by which EPA will complete the rulemaking at issue."

"The deadlines reasonably take into account EPA's available resources and competing priorities," the motion added. "Both parties achieve certainty, and this certainty outweighs the possibility that either party might achieve a better result after protracted and costly litigation."

Tags

  • Agriculture

Related content

News

Bayer, Microsoft develop pilot GenAI for farmers, agronomists; expand digital offering to agri-food industry

Bayer AG has announced the pilot of an expert generative AI (GenAI) system that “quickly and accurately” answers questions related to agronomy, farm management and Bayer agricultural products. The pilot has been developed in collaboration with Microsoft as leading technology partner and Ernst & Young (EY) as an industry partner, the company said. The system is the result of Bayer using proprietary agronomic data to train a large language model (LLM) with years of internal data, insights from thousands of trials within its vast testing network and centuries of aggregated experience from Bayer agronomists around the world, the company said. “Our unique GenAI system has the potential to serve agronomists and benefit farmers all over the world, further advancing AI as an indispensable technology for agriculture,” said Amanda McClerren, CIO and head of digital transformation & information technology for Bayer’s crop science division. Bayer said it is exploring ways to integrate the expert GenAI system into its digital offerings, and the company anticipates broad opportunities for collaboration with other agricultural offerings and partners. “Bayer aims to expand the pilot of the expert GenAI system to selected agronomists and potentially farmers as early as this year, while continuing to advance a separate GenAI prototype allowing users to directly query their own farm data,” the company said. In addition, the partnership between Bayer and Microsoft enables the company to bring ready-made capabilities, AgPowered Services, to the agri-food industry, such as Bayer’s Historical Weather that brings a comprehensive weather dataset to Azure Data Manager for Agriculture that spans the last 40 years and provides detailed, field-level weather insights across global agricultural regions, the company said. Integrating tools from IBM, including from the IBM Environmental Intelligence Suite, the new capability, which was previously available for internal use only, can inform weather risk assessments and actuary processes, Bayer said. It will also be used by Bayer and others to forecast crop seasonality and production changes year over year, as well as train agronomic models, it said. Meanwhile, Bayer is developing a connector that enables access to irrigation data from Lindsay Corp., an industry-leading irrigation solution provider. This expands the data types available to Azure Data Manager's enterprise customers, making it possible for them to connect to irrigation data in the same way as weather, imagery, original equipment manufacturer (OEM) and other data types, the company said. The new cloud offerings will also support regulatory and sustainability reporting, such as providing supply chain traceability that can help ensure compliance with new laws such as the EU Deforestation Regulation, which is expected to go into effect at the end of 2024, Bayer said. This article was first published in chemweek.com. Photo credit: Bayer

News

Infographic: Government policies, trade flows drive Asia's biofuels industry

Asia has seen the fastest growth in biofuels production and exports globally, driven by government policies and export markets for feedstocks. To capitalize on the boom, governments have rapidly pushed out biofuel mandates focused around their country’s main agricultural products. Presently, the largest biofuel producers in the region are China, India, Indonesia, Malaysia, the Philippines and Thailand. Here’s a ready reckoner for Asia’s major biofuel policies along with production, trade and prices. Click for the full-size infographic

News

Food and Beverage Price Index: Four Charts to Watch - March 2024

A snapshot of the latest occurrences across agriculture commodity markets.

News

New satellite launched to expose large polluters of methane

A satellite designed to track and measure methane emissions from leaking oil and gas production sites, in a bid to identify large emitters of methane and help bolster efforts to fight climate change, was successfully launched March 4. MethaneSAT will circle the earth 15 times a day, measuring changes in methane concentrations as small as three parts per billion, non-profit advocacy group Environmental Defense Fund, which developed the program, said in a statement. "MethaneSAT's superpower is the ability to precisely measure methane levels with high resolution over wide areas, including smaller, diffuse sources that account for most emissions in many regions," said Steven Hamburg, EDF's chief scientist and MethaneSAT project leader. "Knowing how much methane is coming from where and how the rates are changing is essential." Methane is a much more powerful climate pollutant than carbon dioxide, with estimates suggesting it is more than 80 times more potent than CO2 over a 20-year time frame. The energy sector -- including oil, natural gas, coal and bioenergy -- accounts for nearly 40% of methane emissions from human activity. The satellite was developed by a consortium of universities and companies such as Bezos Earth Fund, Arnold Ventures, New Zealand Space Agency, Harvard University, BAE Systems and IO Aerospace. The data from MethaneSAT will help both companies and regulators to track emissions, and "give stakeholders -- citizens, governments, investors, and gas importers -- free, near-real time access to the data, and the unprecedented ability to compare the results against emission goals and obligations," EDF said in a statement. The interactive emissions data will be made available on MethaneSAT's website and on geospatial platform Google Earth Engine. Methane pledges This initiative comes a few months after several oil and natural gas producers pledged to reduce their carbon emissions to net zero by 2050 and curb methane emissions to near zero by 2030. Under the agreement, signed at the 28th UN Climate Change Conference in Dubai, 50 companies committed to setting interim targets that would reduce methane emissions to 0.2% of oil and natural gas production by 2030, and to end routine flaring. What makes this pledge distinctive is that it will be scrutinized using technology and data, with MethaneSAT providing key data. The United Nations Environment Program's International Methane Emissions Observatory (IMEO), the Environmental Defense Fund, Bloomberg Philanthropies and the International Energy Agency will help monitor compliance by tracking methane emissions using satellite data, and other analytical tools. The agreement is part of a Global Decarbonization Accelerator launched at COP28, focused on three pillars: energy systems of the future such as renewables and hydrogen; the fossil fuel sector and emission-intensive industries; and methane. Methane intensity Methane emissions generated by production are a significant contributor to the carbon intensity of natural gas. Platts, part of S&P Global Commodity Insights, assesses methane performance certificates traded in the spot market that represent low methane emissions in natural gas production in the US and Canada. Each MPC represents 1 MMBtu of gas with zero methane emissions produced. Platts reflects MPCs that have been issued against production that has a methane intensity of less than 0.10%. Prices have recovered to $0.024/MPC on March 5 after having fallen to just $0.008/MPC in mid-August, with very little demand for the certificates at present, S&P Global data showed.