FEATURE: The demise of Venezuela's once thriving HBI industry

Banner Image

Current global steel market dynamics should have presented the Venezuelan hot-briquetted iron industry with a golden opportunity.  

That is, if only Venezuela's HBI industry was in a position to take advantage of such a scenario. Global metals supply has been dented by Russia's war with Ukraine, the use of direct-reduced iron and HBI combined with hydrogen are emerging as a key route for steel decarbonization and research has shown HBI utilization in blast furnaces lessens the rate of coke usage while enhancing quality and stretching hot metal production.

With a reported installed capacity of 6.9 million mt/year, the Venezuelan HBI sector certainly should be a hot topic. However, the story is quite the opposite.

Venezuela's five HBI producers – Orinoco Iron, Venprecar, BriqVen, Comsigua and Ferrominera – have been operating at less than 10% of their installed capacities after being restarted in September 2021 following a nearly year-long hiatus. Any supply they can offer has been focused mainly on the domestic market or used to repay debts to former trading partners, sources said.  

Sanctions hit hard 

Venezuela's production of HBI, iron ore and steel have been hampered for years in the wake of US sanctions imposed on the country's oil sector in 2019. The sanctions disrupted raw material supply and natural gas and energy production. The government struggled as financing dwindled and an economic crisis engulfed the nation.

With the sanctionsin effect, shipping companies stopped sending vessels to Venezuela and removed all remaining ships from the country by Sept. 4, 2019.  

"No one was willing to take the risk of remaining in Venezuela and possibly suffering retaliation from the US," one source said. 

Moreover, Venezuela'sdomestic issues were further spelling the end of its HBI export activity.  

Venezuela was formerly the world's largest exporter of HBI, but in 2019 it exported less than 400,000 mt, sources estimated, compared with about 7 million mt roughly a decade before, in 2008. Venezuelan HBI had been exported to 36 destinations, with Mexico and European its most frequent destinations.   

Apart from large HBI producers Russia and the US, suppliers in Malaysia, India, Iran and Libya usually export surplus material to regional markets. 

Trade and pricing decisions 

With the start of the Russia Ukraine war in late February, buyers from Oman, India, Mexico, Poland, UK and Slovenia were checking Venezuela's ability to send 30,000 mt HBI cargoes, with traditional suppliers in Malaysia and the US booked for several months ahead.  

"I spoke to Venezuelan companies, and they said the financial debt to China was very high, so all their HBI availability was booked for them, but a long time ago," one agent said. 

The agent added that it's been over a year since regular trades have been reported involving Venezuelan HBI, with European traders refusing to entertain deal with corruption "and the demands for prepayments ranging from 80%-100% of the cargo value." 

Since 2019, trade and pricing decisions related to HBI have been centralized with the Corporacion Venezolana de Guayana, or CVG, which is controlled directly by Venezuela's office of the president. A fixed-price mechanism was implemented by government authorities, in which a $260-$265/mt FOB range was considered for standard-quality cargoes with 88.3% Fe content. 

However, given the lack of appropriate raw material, HBI Fe content has widely varied among producers and dropped constantly over the years.

Historically, HBI was usually negotiated at a discount to Turkish imported scrap, but it has lagged behind in recent years due to a dearth of negotiations.

S&P Global Commodity Insights clarifies Venezuelan HBI FOB assessment

A doomed industry? 

Many market participants question whether there is hope for the Venezuelan HBI industry to return to its former global stature.  

The premises on which it was established remain the same: Plentiful natural gas, large iron ore reserves, a well-situated river, the Orinoco, with access to the Atlantic Ocean and specialized labor.  

"However, by the time the industry was nationalized, in May 2009, the sector gradually deteriorated amid poor management, coupled with government officials placed in positions without technical knowledge," a source familiar with the government's role in the industry's operations said. 

The construction of a second 3 million mt/year pellet line by Venezuela's sole iron ore producer, Ferrominera Orinoco, headed by China's Metallurgical Group (MCC Group), did not take into consideration that DR-grade pellets production was the exclusive goal.  

"HBI is made of DR-grade pellets exclusively," the source said. "But they built a blast furnace pellets facility." 

The direct consequence, he added, was a 40% reduction in general HBI production. Plus, FMO's iron ore has high phosphorus content, which ultimately reduces HBI quality.  

"It would be naturally sold at a discount to Metalloinvest/ArcelorMittal's Texas Corpus Christi material," another source said. Metalloinvest and AM are the largest producers in Russia and US, respectively.

Over the years, sources said experienced labor working at the facilities left Ciudad Guayana looking for better work and living conditions elsewhere. Venezuela's electricity grid also has deteriorated, supplying only one third of the industry needs.  

Moreover, "Venezuela has gas supply from natural wells and associated petroleum gas," one of the market sources said, adding that HBI producers can only take the gas from oil wells because their production units are located far from natural gas wells. 

 "This means that if we pump oil, we have gas. If we do not pump oil, we do not have gas," he added. 

However, state oil company PDVSA has seen output plummet after the imposition of sanctions and is unlikely to rebound for years and skittish foreign investors are not expected to infuse the much-needed cash into the nation's crumbling oil fields, upgraders, pipelines, refineries and ports. 

The Orinoco, which gives access to the Atlantic Ocean hasn't been dredged for years – which means its draft is too low and logistics another issue for the sector.

"Vessels are unable to load full cargoes, causing a considerable hike in freight levels, as Handymax and Supramax vessels are forced to depart short-loaded, or top-off could be needed," one source said.  

Ultimately, facilities have been slowly dismantled and sold as scrap metal for neighboring countries and most recently to Turkey. And a billion dollar revival plan by the government, announced several times in past years but without a detailed program, seems by far an impossible move. 

"You can't look to Venezuela as a quick response to HBI supply; it would take decades to reestablish the industry there," one observer said.  

Tags

  • Metals & Mining

Related content

News

South Korea's L&F to supply $9.95 bil of cathode materials to SK On over 6 years

South Korea's L&F Co signed a $9.95 billion deal to supply high-nickel cathode material to battery maker SK On over the next six years, the cathode materials company said March 25. The value of the supply contract was estimated by L&F and is effective March 22, 2024 to Dec. 21, 2030, as it builds up its supply of battery-related materials. High-nickel cathodes are necessary to extend the lifespan and capacity of secondary batteries. To boost its local production capacities, South Korea's Fair Trade Commission approved a plan by L&F to set up a joint-venture 120,000 mt/year battery precursor plant at Samangeum Industriale Complex, Gunsan, as early as 2025 to 2026, together with LS Corp. Also, the supply of the cathode material will be vital to SK On, which plans to start up its third electric vehicle battery plant at Seosan in 2025 with a production capacity of 14 GWh. In a related development, SK On will supply its high-nickel batteries to Swedish EV maker Polestar from 2025. Platts assessed spot battery-grade nickel sulfate with minimum 22% nickel content and maximum 100 ppb magnetic material at Yuan 30,500/mt ($4,238/mt) DDP China March 22, up Yuan 500/mt from the previous session, S&P Global Commodity Insights data showed. Platts Connect: News & Insights (spglobal.com)

News

Australia’s Pilbara, China’s Ganfeng to study setup of JV lithium plant

To consider conversion plant with 32,000 mt/year LCE output Uncertainty risks remain in China’s lithium markets Australian miner Pilbara Minerals said March 25 it signed a binding term sheet to complete a joint feasibility study on a downstream lithium conversion plant with China's Ganfeng Lithium Group, one of the world's largest lithium chemical converters. Global lithium salts prices have dived significantly in the recent past due to supply surplus amid expanding capacity and weakening demand. The feasibility study will consider a conversion plant that could produce 32,000 mt/year lithium carbonate equivalent of lithium chemicals (hydroxide and/or carbonate), along with a potential intermediate lithium chemical product in Australia, leveraging Ganfeng’s experience as a lithium chemical converter, Pilbara said in the statement. The feasibility study is expected to be completed in the March quarter of 2025, with an option to progress to a final investment decision and formation of a joint venture following that. This was not the first attempt for Pilbara Minerals to move into lithium chemicals conversion business. The company has made an FID in August 2023 for a demonstration plant within the Pilgangoora Operation JV in Western Australia with environmental technology developer Calix. Calix said the project was estimated to produce more than 3,000 mt/year of lithium phosphate at full capacity, using spodumene concentrate feed purchased by the JV from Pilbara on commercial terms consistent with market pricing. The plant was expected to produce first lithium salt in the June quarter of 2025 and ramp up to steady state production in the March quarter of 2026, Calix said. Cooperation with Ganfeng Lithium This was the first time Pilbara and Ganfeng Lithium are working together on a downstream lithium conversion plant. It could help Ganfeng Lithium lessen the impact from the US Inflation Reduction Act to establish the plant outside China. However, when and where the project would be situated remained unknown, industry sources said. Ganfeng Lithium held a 5.76% stake in Pilbara as of the first half of 2023, according to an interim report. Pilbara previously bumped up its supply of spodumene concentrate to China’s Ganfeng Lithium Group in January. According to an amendment made to an offtake agreement, Pilbara will supply spodumene to Ganfeng Lithium in the range of 260,000-310,000 mt/year over 2024-2026. Lithium carbonate prices Lithium carbonate prices in China plunged 85% from their peak seen in 2022 to a low of Yuan 90,000/mt ($12,487) in early January. The prices have moved up since then to Yuan 112,350/mt as of March 22, according to S&P Global Commodity Insights data. However, prices would continue to face pressure as downstream consumers have almost finished restocking while imports have stayed elevated and a small number of lithium salt producers in Jiangxi province planned to resume production, sources said. Market participants are keeping a close eye on the recovery of downstream demand in the upcoming peak season. The most active lithium carbonate contracts for July 2024 delivery on the Guangzhou Futures Exchange closed at Yuan 107,400/mt March 25, down 6.6% or Yuan 7,600/mt from the previous settled price, GFE data showed. The price direction highlighted the uncertainty risks in China’s lithium markets, sources said. Platts Connect: News & Insights (spglobal.com)

News

EU, Norway sign MOU on raw materials, battery value chains

MOU to develop into long-term cooperation in five areas First business match-making event to take place in April The EU and Norway signed a memorandum of understanding launching a strategic partnership to develop sustainable land-based raw materials and battery value chains, the European Commission said March 21. The MOU -- a building bloc of the EU-Norway Green Alliance announced in April 2023 -- is meant to lead to long-term cooperation between the EU and Norway in five areas: integration of raw material and battery value chains through joint projects and ventures; research and innovation; information exchange around environmental, social and governance (ESG) standards and practices; mobilization of financial instruments, notably through Invest EU, the European Raw Materials Alliance and the European Battery Alliance; and developing skills for high-quality jobs in the sectors. The EU and Norway will now work on implementing the roadmap for the partnership with the first business match-making event planned during the Hannover Messe trade fair on April 22. The MOU rests on the strength of Norway as a country rich in rare earths, magnesium, titanium, vanadium, phosphate rock and other resources, and with a large processing capacity for a few of these minerals, to which the EU adds value as an established and growing market for green technologies, including batteries with an estimated demand in 2023 of 175 GWh. The EU battery industry is the second largest in the world with existing facilities having up to 220 GWh of ramp-up capacity and an additional 1 TWh of battery manufacturing projects that have been announced or are currently under construction, according to the commission. With critical raw materials needed to deliver on green energy objectives, the commission has started to build a series of partnerships on raw materials with Canada and Ukraine in 2021, Kazakhstan and Namibia in 2022, Argentina, Chile, Zambia, the Democratic Republic of Congo and Greenland in 2023, and Rwanda in 2024. The partnerships are in line with the Global Gateway strategy, through which the EU will mobilize up to Eur300 billion ($325 billion), it says. Platts Connect: News & Insights (spglobal.com)

News

CERAWEEK: Energy industry has trapped itself with binary technology talk

Industry must be open to new technologies Wind, solar attack natural gas’ market share The energy industry has trapped itself with binary dialogue about being for one type of technology or another, when all resources need to work together to achieve energy transition goals, Tinker Energy Associates CEO Scott Tinker said March 22. The energy transition is not just about one technology, but rather a suite of technologies, panelists said at the CERAWeek by S&P Global energy conference in Houston. “What is nice about renewables and new technology is they're much more democratically distributed around the world,” said Andres Gluski, AES Corporation president and CEO. “The reality is a little bit more complicated. But I also think it's not rocket science.” However, the industry has to be careful about status quo because things are changing rapidly, Gluski added. “In the power industry, we're seeing once in a 100-year events, like floods and heatwaves, etc., occur every year.,” Gluski said. “The weather has changed. That’s the reality.” Industry leaders need to look at how to deliver the electricity with the lowest carbon and in most sustainable way possible, he added. Renewables versus fossil fuels Solar and wind costs have dropped remarkably over the years, Tinker said. “To make it reliable requires something sitting here waiting to back it up … and that something is expensive,” Tinker said about battery storage. “I think we have to be more open and candid about the actual cost of electricity to be integrated.” The domestic production of wind turbines is strong, with battery storage production to come, while domestic of solar panels will take longer, Gluski said. And while renewables do not generate 24 hours a day, coal is not going to come back regardless of political slogans, he added. “For a lot of these new technologies we need the regulators to be on top of it as a lot more is coming," Gluski said. The energy transition has to happen at a pace that’s politically sustainable, said David Victor, a professor of Innovation and Public Policy with the School of Global Policy and Strategy at University of California, San Diego. “I'm really concerned that we are overweighting the familiar,” Victor said. “We are overinvesting in things we know how to do and probably underinvesting in things that we don't yet know how to do.” Glue that holds it together “We got to figure out the glue that holds all this together,” said Hunter Hunt, chairman and CEO of Hunt Energy. There will be less natural gas needed than the industry thinks, but more than environmentalists think, he added. “Wind and solar are absolutely attacking natural gas’ share and they've decimated coal in the industrialized world,” Hunt said. “If natural gas is going to be a transition fuel, the industry needs to do its part to make sure that we're doing it in the right way. The future of energy can be seen in Texas today, Hunt said about the battery storage growth happening. There such a diversity in approaches with new technology and “we need all of it,” said Evelyn Wang, director of the Advanced Research Projects Agency-Energy with the United States Department of Energy. Houston, we have an opportunity “One of the things that is different today versus this time last year, is just explosion of activity in energy transition-related projects in Houston and Gulf Coast,” said Bobby Tudor, CEO Artemis Energy Partners and chairman of the Houston Energy Transition Initiative. “We have enormous competitive advantages here in this region to be a leader, and it's up to us to intentionally do that. … We intend to continue to exploit that advantage.” Texas has the largest concentration of technical talent in the world related to energy systems, Tudor said, adding the state is well positioned for the task due to its ports and access to wind and solar resources. A lot of the development in Texas has to do with permitting and the ability to get projects permitted and done, Tudor said, adding that process is much more difficult in rest of the country. The catch phrase should be “Houston, we have an opportunity” instead of “Houston, we have a problem,” said Atul Arya, S&P Global Commodity Insights senior vice president and chief energy strategist.