Commodities 2023: Recession fears, ample stocks cloud picture for US steel sheet market

Banner Image

The US steel sheet market will look to establish new footing in 2023 after prices took a nosedive in the second half of 2022. However, concerns of a weaker economy, sufficient inventory levels and uncertain demand outlooks are weighing on the market's potential upside for next year.

The Platts TSI US hot-rolled coil (HRC) index reached a record level of nearly $2,000/st in the third quarter of 2021 and a 2022 year-to-date high of $1,500/st in April, according to data from S&P Global Commodity Insights. Prices then declined steeply until bottoming out at $620/st in November. Market participants have noted slowing demand that could extend well into 2023 with a cooling economy linked to inflationary pressures, interest rate hikes and other factors.

In response to softer market conditions and encouraged by shorter steel mill lead times, steel buyers have said they are now opting to stay on the sidelines while they work down well-stocked inventories and control costs. Some sources are also planning to rely more heavily on contractual supply in 2023, rather than spot market sales.

Most major North American steel producers in late November began announcing increases to their base offer prices for steel sheet in an attempt to reverse downward price trends. US HRC prices have since climbed back up to over $650/st in December, but industry sources are unsure whether the mill offers will be fully accepted by the market going into 2023.

One US Midwest service center source said the mill increases and higher scrap prices could support a rebound in HRC prices, at least temporarily.

"I'm not sure how long it lasts, but in the near term, it looks to be in favor of the mills getting prices up," the source added.

However, a Canadian buy-side source said he hadn't seen a real change in demand since the latest round of price increases. "I am still sort of in the camp of let's give it a bit and let it play out," the source said.

Could $700/st be a floor or ceiling in 2023?

Steel producers could be eying $700/st as a new price floor for HRC. In a more aggressive move, steelmaker Cleveland-Cliffs said Dec. 13 it would set a minimum base price for HRC at $750/st. Cliffs is the largest steel sheet producer by volume in the US.

By Dec. 15, the Platts HRC assessment reached $690/st. Despite the uptick in prices, a trader said demand remained subdued.

"The price has stabilized, but no one is rushing to buy from US mills and definitely not imports," he said on the same day as the Cliffs announcement.

Another trader said prices could hold at this higher level if steel mill capacity utilization stays lower compared with historical levels. The source also noted difficulty in booking import volumes.

S&P Global analysts forecast monthly average US HRC prices to bounce between $650/st and $700/st for most of 2023, possibly breaching that range to reach about $720/st in December.

"At this stage, we're looking at an average of $663/st for 2023 but acknowledge there could be downside to this price level if recessionary conditions bite," S&P Global said in its most recent forecast released in November. "US steel prices have been on such a rollercoaster over the past three years that it is difficult to know if pre-COVID or pre-Ukraine invasion prices are closer to a real price level."

Monthly contracts for US HRC prices on the London Metal Exchange are currently holding at $707.50/st for each month in 2023 starting in February, as of Dec. 15.

Demand outlook

The World Steel Association, or worldsteel, offered a somewhat favorable view of US steel demand for 2023 in its most recent outlook released in October, saying it did not expect market contraction with positive momentum in the automotive sector, spending from the country's new infrastructure law and rising energy sector investment.

However, potential risks to US steel demand in 2023 include softer manufacturing activity, a shift in consumer spending from goods to services, a slowdown from the recent housing boom and a delayed recovery in the non-residential construction sector, the association added.

With an uncertain demand outlook, the steel market will also monitor whether the slate of new steel sheet capacity ramping up from electric arc furnaces in 2023 will pressure HRC prices.

Steel sheet capacity ramp ups in 2023
Producer
Mill location
New capacity volume
Type
Nucor
Ghent, Kentucky
1.4 million st
Mill expansion
Steel Dynamics
Sinton, Texas
3 million st
Greenfield mill
Arcelor Mittal-Nippon Steel
Calvert, Alabama
1.5 million st
Mill expansion
North Star BlueScope
Delta, Ohio
~900,000 st
Mill expansion

Meanwhile, only two major mills will start 2023 with some capacity offline.

Idled blast furnaces at start of 2023
Producer
Mill location
Capacity offline
US Steel
Gary, Indiana
1.5 million st
US Steel
Braddock, Pennsylvania
1.4 million st

Tags

  • Metals & Mining

Related content

News

Infographic: China’s property market remains a drag on steel demand

China's property sector has been in shambles over the past few years and remains the biggest drag on domestic steel demand. The property market has trended downwards in the first quarter of 2024. With no major recovery signs in new home sales, China’s new home construction starts are likely to remain on the downwards trajectory in the foreseeable future. The slowing property sector has triggered debt risks locally, leading Beijing to order local governments to downsize infrastructure projects, which has also undermined the growth momentum in infrastructure steel needs, adding to the demand slump. Click here to see full-size image

News

China's BTR to start up anode materials plant in Indonesia by end-2024: Syrah

Plant will have an output of 80,000 mt/year Syrah delivered 10,000 mt of graphite fines to PT Indonesia BTR Chinese graphite exports "extremely limited" over Jan-Feb Chinese anode material producer BTR New Material Group is expected to start up an 80,000-mt/year active anode materials plant at Indonesia's Morowali Industrial Park, Central Sulawesi province, by the end of 2024, Australia-listed graphite producer Syrah Resources said April 8. The $478 million AAM plant will process synthetic graphite, supplied by Syrah and other suppliers, into anode materials. At the same time, Australia's Evolution Energy Minerals, in which BTR owns a 9.9% stake, is expected to supply 100% of the fine flake graphite produced from its Chilalo project in Tanzania to BTR for three years. Syrah said on the same date that it delivered a 10,000-mt break bulk shipment of natural graphite fines from its Balama graphite operation in Mozambique to PT Indonesia BTR New Energy Materials in Indonesia. The future of Syrah's Balama operation, which has a production capacity of about 350,000 mt/year, will be determined by the impact of China's export controls on the global market. China implemented export controls on natural graphite and its products, effective Dec. 1, 2023 . Citing January-February data from China's General Administration of Customs, "natural graphite fines and coarse flake exports were extremely limited," Syrah said. "Purified spherical graphite exports were 25%-40% of the 2023 monthly average and limited to South Korea." The 10,000-mt cargo to BTR is Syrah's "first large volume natural graphite sale to a battery supply chain participant destination outside China," Syrah said, following a trial shipment made in the first quarter of 2024. The delivery of the graphite cargo to Indonesia comes after Syrah signed a six-year deal to supply natural graphite fines to South Korea's Posco Future M in March . Data from S&P Global Commodity Insights showed that Platts assessed spot prices of natural flake graphite at $465/mt CIF Northeast Asia on April 5, flat from the session before, and spherical graphite at $2,060/mt CIF Northeast Asia, also unchanged from the previous session. Platts Connect: News & Insights (spglobal.com)

News

UK battery recycler Altilium completes expansion of battery recycling center

More processing of CAM, battery precursors for qualification with OEMs Center to focus on reducing CAPEX, OPEX; improving metal recovery rates Company to implement processes at commercial scale at planned Teesside recycling hub UK-based clean technology company Altilium has completed the expansion of its cathode active materials and EV battery recycling innovation center in Plymouth, it said April 5. The site has been expanded from 10,000 sq ft to 18,000 sq ft with the staff headcount increased to 70, it said in a statement. Without disclosing specific volumes, the company said the expansion would allow it to process larger volumes of CAM and battery precursors for qualification with OEM’s and battery cell manufacturers. Work completed on the facility includes a major electrical upgrade required to power the recycling facility, start-up EV battery recycling test bed and equipment procurement. Altilium said the innovation center, known as Act 2, would focus on reducing CAPEX and OPEX of future plants and improving the rates of metal recovery, particularly for lithium. The company plans to implement these processes at its planned Teesside recycling hub (Act 4). Announced in November, the Teesside facility, designed by engineering consultancy Hatch, will have the capacity to process approximately 50,000 mt/year of black mass. When batteries are manufactured or reach their end of life, production offcuts or used batteries can be collected, dismantled and shredded to produce black mass, from which critical metals including lithium, nickel, cobalt and manganese can be extracted. The plant will comprise two processing facilities: a chemical plant producing 95,000 mt/year of battery precursors including lithium carbonate and nickel sulfate, and a cathode active material plant producing 30,000 mt/year of CAM. The company said the facility, once fully operational, will meet around 20% of the UK’s CAM requirements. The recycling of black mass has become increasingly important as a supplement to virgin material supply, as well as to reduce the carbon footprint in the battery supply chain. In addition to its Teesside battery recycling plant, Altilium is also retrofitting its existing SX-EW hydrometallurgy plant in Bulgaria to produce battery intermediates MHP and lithium sulfate. The plant is being upgraded to process up to 8,000 mt/year of black mass, with commercial operations expected to start this year. On Feb. 22, SQM Lithium Ventures said is had increased its investment in Altilium by $9.43 million, bringing its total contribution to $12 million. The funding, done through SQM's investment arm SQM Capital Ventures, was part of the Series A financing round. Altilium’s Series B financing, which will focus exclusively on the Teesside project, is expected to launch during 2024, with the plant itself expected to take around 36 months to construct. Platts, part of S&P Global Commodity Insights, assessed cobalt payables for Ni-Co black mass ex-works Europe at 52% basis European cobalt metal 99.8% April 2, down 3 percentage points on the day and on the week. Platts assessed nickel payables at 52% basis LME nickel April 2, also down 3 percentage points on the day and on the week. Platts Connect: News & Insights (spglobal.com)

News

Minerals Security Partnership launches forum to expand cooperation on critical raw materials

To build on EU's Critical Raw Materials Package Support, accelerate implementation of sustainable critical minerals projects The EU, US and other countries in the Minerals Security Partnership (MSP) have launched the MSP Forum to expand cooperation on critical raw materials required for the global green and digital transitions, the European Commission said in an April 5 statement. The MSP partners were joined by Kazakhstan, Namibia, Ukraine and Uzbekistan to launch the platform, it said, which will be co-led by the US and the EU. The EC added that the recently announced Critical Raw Materials Club would become a full part of the MSP Forum, bringing together resource-rich countries and countries with high demand for the resources. “This will create a greater, more ambitious joint initiative linked to the Minerals Security Partnership, where the European Commission represents the EU,” it said. The MSP Forum aims to build on the EU's Critical Raw Materials Package adopted in March 2023 and will form a project group to support and accelerate the implementation of sustainable critical minerals projects, the EC said. The forum will also create a policy dialogue to identify policies for boosting sustainable production and local capacities, facilitate regulatory cooperation to foster fair competition, transparency and predictability and promote high environmental, social and governance standards in critical raw material supply chains, the EC said. “The MSP Forum is a cornerstone of the EU’s strategy to secure a more sustainable supply of critical raw materials,” EC Executive Vice-President and Commissioner for Trade Valdis Dombrovskis said, adding that it would be key to reducing vulnerabilities and achieving the green and digital transition in Europe and globally. “With this global initiative, we want to make sure that international cooperation is up to the task of increasing investment, diversifying supply chains and bringing sustainable benefits to all parties,” he said. Critical raw materials are needed for numerous technologies in the energy transition, resulting in high demand, although supply is hindered by geopolitical, environmental and social risks and challenges. The EC estimates that EU demand for lithium used in electric vehicle batteries and energy storage will increase twelve-fold by 2030. Platts, part of S&P Global Commodity Insights, put both battery grade lithium carbonate and hydroxide assessments at $14,500/mt CIF Europe on April 4, both stable on the day and on the week, and down from $15,800/mt on Jan. 2. The EC said any partners that were ready to commit to the key MSP principles would be allowed to join the MSP Forum, noting that these principles included diversification of global supply chains and high environmental standards, good governance and fair working conditions. The co-leaders and current MSP partners plan to reach out to prospective members in North and South America, Africa, Asia and Europe to expand the Forum’s participation and start working within the project and policy dialogue groups. Besides the EU and US, the current MSP partners are Australia, Canada, Estonia, Finland, France, Germany, India, Italy, Japan, Norway, South Korea, Sweden and the UK. EU, Uzbekistan sign MOU In a separate statement, the EC announced that the EU and Uzbekistan had signed a memorandum of understanding to launch a strategic partnership on critical raw materials, which it said “underscored the partners' shared commitment to enhance cooperation in the field of critical raw material.” Under the partnership, the EU and Uzbekistan will work on establishing an operational roadmap with concrete implementation actions, the EC said. The partnership will focus on cooperating on the integration of sustainable value chains, increasing the resilience of supply chains and enhancing the transparency of measures related to investments, operations and exports. It will also focus on the mobilization of funding for projects resulting from the partnership and the development of infrastructure required for the development of value chains, as well as on cooperation to achieve sustainable and responsible production and sourcing of critical raw material, on research and innovation, and on building capacity to enforce relevant rules and on developing training and skills. Platts Connect: News & Insights (spglobal.com)